Double Stroller vs Wagon: Which 1 is Better for Family Outings?

Double stroller vs wagon: When out and about with young kids, transporting them smoothly is key. Two popular options for families with multiples or children close in age are double strollers and wagons. But should you choose a double stroller or a wagon for hassle-free family adventures?

In this in-depth comparison, we’ll examine the pros and cons of double strollers versus wagons to help you decide which is best for your needs. Keep reading for a detailed breakdown of factors like maneuverability, portability, seating, and more to pick the right kid-hauling gear.

Whether you plan on using a double stroller or a wagon, especially in situations where you need to hold up to 4 children or carry a baby carrier, this guide will help you determine the better option for your family’s unique needs.

Double strollers are ideal for parents with two or more young kids, but wagons can accommodate even larger groups, allowing you to carry all the essentials for your family outings.

Find out which one is easier to navigate and the perfect fit for your specific requirements, especially if you have a small car or need a practical solution for transporting multiple children.

Introducing the Double Stroller and the Wagon

First, let’s overview the double stroller and the wagon:

A double stroller has seats and restraints specifically designed for two small children, usually side-by-side or front-to-back, with safety harnesses to keep them secure during family trips. These strollers are known for their safety features and are a go-to choice for parents with twins or siblings of a similar age.

On the other hand, a wagon is a cart on wheels meant for general utility purposes but often used to transport kids with benches or jump seats. While wagons are designed to accommodate two children or more, they generally lack the safety harnesses found in double strollers. However, their larger wheels make them a great option for those who find double strollers difficult to maneuver or have a need for a baby carriage designed to carry kids during family outings. When deciding between the two, consider the safety and maneuverability factors to determine which suits your family’s needs best.

Some key differences affect which one is optimal, so let’s compare them in detail:

Double stroller vs wagon: Key Features Table

Key Feature	Double Stroller	Wagon	Winner
Seating	Multiple adjustable seats designed for children	Bench seats or open-top design	Double Stroller
Safety Harnesses	5-point harnesses and child restraints	Usually no built-in restraints	Double Stroller
Maneuverability	Swiveling front wheels, easy to steer	Fewer maneuverability features	Double Stroller
Storage Space	Designated storage options	Open storage space	Wagon
Age Suitability	Suitable for children of various ages, including newborns	Better for kids over age 2	Double Stroller
Folding Capability	Folds into a compact form for storage and transportation	Usually remains open and rigid	Double Stroller
Use on Public Transit	Generally accepted on public transportation	Some restrictions due to size	Double Stroller
All-Terrain Wheels	Options available for various terrains	May have larger wheels for specific conditions	Double Stroller

Weight and Size Comparison

Double strollers range from 21-35 lbs, which is significantly lighter than the 35-50 lb average weight of wagons. This means that strollers are designed to be easier to lift, carry, and maneuver, which is particularly beneficial if you plan to get away with a single stroller for your child. Strollers are also easier to fold and more compact, making them a great choice if you need to put them in the trunk of a taxi or store them in a limited space at home. Additionally, strollers, especially umbrella-style ones, have smaller folded dimensions, making them a practical option for parents on the go.

While the long bench seat of a wagon may be more comfortable for a 2-year-old, it’s essential to consider that strollers are generally designed for babies and toddlers, offering the convenience of attaching a car seat or bassinet for newborns.

Another advantage of strollers is that they are easier to push and fit through standard doorways, ensuring a hassle-free experience during your family adventures.

Seating and Restraints Comparison

Strollers are equipped with 5-point harnesses, including waist straps and crotch posts, which are specifically designed to secure children safely and comfortably within the seat. These harnesses are essential for ensuring that your little ones remain securely in place while using the stroller, especially when in motion.

On the other hand, most wagons lack built-in restraints like the 5-point harness found in strollers. They typically feature flat benches, making them versatile for various uses but not as suitable for securing young passengers during transit. The stroller seat is thoughtfully contoured to match a child’s shape and designed with their safety in mind.

In contrast, wagon seats are flat benches, which are excellent for different uses but may not provide the same level of comfort and safety for children, particularly those who are younger.

Strollers are well-known for accommodating children at various developmental stages, and many models offer options for attaching infant car seats, making them suitable for families with a newborn and a toddler.

In contrast, wagons are better suited for older kids, typically those over the age of 2, and may not be the best choice for families with multiple children in different age groups, like a newborn and a toddler.

Therefore, if you’re navigating public transit or need a compact stroller for your family adventures, it’s worth considering the safety and versatility offered by strollers.

Maneuverability and Steering

Double strollers are known for their excellent maneuverability, featuring swiveling front wheels and adjustable handles. These design features make steering and turning with a double stroller a breeze, even in tight spaces, which can be incredibly convenient when transporting kids.

On the other hand, wagons usually come equipped with four fixed wheels that lack the swivel function. As a result, they tend to be harder to maneuver, especially in situations that require tight turns or navigating through crowded areas. However, the long handle on a wagon provides good control and stability, making it easier to handle when you’re out and about with your children.

Another noteworthy aspect is that strollers designed for two kids can often be pushed with one hand. This feature can be a significant advantage for parents who may need one hand free for other tasks or simply prefer the convenience of single-handed navigation. In contrast, wagons typically require the use of both hands to steer effectively, which is something to consider when deciding between a double stroller and a wagon for transporting kids. 

So, when determining whether a double stroller or a wagon with multiple children is the better option for your family, it’s essential to take into account the stroller’s maneuverability and the ease of use provided by all-terrain wheels and the stroller’s design.

Portability for Travel and Storage

Double strollers come with the added advantage of being easily foldable into a compact form when not in use. This feature makes them a great option if you’re looking for a stroller that you can conveniently stow away in your car trunk or at home. Their compact nature ensures they won’t take up much space, even in smaller living areas.

On the other hand, wagons typically remain open and rigid, which means they occupy more space when they’re not actively in use. However, it’s worth noting that some folding wagon options are available in the market if storage space is a concern for you.

Furthermore, when it comes to maneuverability, double strollers tend to outshine bulky wagons. They are designed to fit in tight spaces such as elevators and store aisles with ease. This maneuverability can be a key factor for parents who frequently navigate crowded areas or need a stroller that’s versatile and compact.

In summary, the decision between a double stroller and a wagon to accommodate two children involves several considerations, including the ease of folding and storing the stroller when not in use and the maneuverability required for navigating different environments.

Safety and Balance Comparison

Strollers are equipped with harness straps that serve the essential function of keeping kids stable, balanced, and securely seated. These safety harnesses are a vital component in ensuring your child’s safety during your outings, particularly when they are seated in the stroller. The sturdy and adjustable harness system in strollers effectively prevents the risk of children falling or attempting to climb out, providing parents with peace of mind.

Conversely, wagons typically lack built-in restraints, which means that young kids in wagons may be more prone to accidents. Without proper restraints, children may be tempted to stand or lean over the sides, increasing the risk of falling out. For this reason, close supervision is always required when children are riding in a wagon.

It’s also worth noting that the lower center of gravity in strollers makes them inherently less likely to tip over. This characteristic provides an added layer of safety, especially when navigating various terrains or uneven surfaces. On the other hand, wagons placed on inclines or uneven ground can more easily tip backward due to their design and the absence of secure restraints.

In the end, the safety features in strollers, such as harness straps, are designed to minimize the risk of accidents and provide a secure environment for your child while you’re on the go. This is a crucial consideration, especially for families with multiple kids or those who frequently use public transportation. Remember that safety should always be a top priority when deciding between strollers and wagons, and it’s an essential factor to consider as you invest in a mode of transportation for your children, be it a stroller or a wagon like the popular Radio Flyer models.

Weather Protection Features

• Double strollers often come with rain covers or UV-protection canopies to shield children from sun and rain.
• Wagon canopies and covers are available as add-ons, but aren’t as cohesive or protective. Separate rain gear would be needed.

Storage and Convenience Factors

• Below the seat, strollers offer basket storage for kid’s items and parent supplies. Many wagons lack storage.
• However, the wagon’s open design makes loading bulkier items like beach gear or picnics easier.
• Double strollers often allow use of two infant car seats if babies are small. This isn’t possible with a wagon.

Riding Smoothness Comparison

• Strollers designed for two provide a smoother ride with features like shocks and suspension that minimize bumps.
• Wagons typically have no suspension system, so the ride is rougher and more jostling over uneven terrain. Pneumatic tires help somewhat.

Cost Considerations

• Average wagons cost $100-300. Basic options are affordable, but larger or luxury models get pricier.
• Double strollers range from $300 on the low end for umbrellas up to $700-800 for premium doubles.
• Considering the safety features and smoother ride, double strollers provide good value for the cost.

Pros and Cons of Double Strollers

Pros and Cons of Double Strollers

Key Factors to Consider in Your Decision

When choosing between a double stroller and a wagon, keep these factors foremost:

• Ages of children – Strollers for babies and toddlers, wagons for ages 2+
• Transport in vehicles – Strollers take up minimal space
• Locations you’ll use it – Smooth vs. rugged terrain
• Frequency of use – Daily vs. occasional
• Portability needs – Storage size, moving through doors and aisles
• Budget – Wagons are more affordable

Prioritize safety and your children’s needs when determining which option best suits your family and lifestyle.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Our Recommendations: Double Stroller vs. Wagon

Based on this comprehensive comparison, here’s guidance on which is preferable:

Go with a double stroller if:

• You have twins or kids under age 2
• Regularly taking public transit
• Usage is daily for errands and transportation
• Seeking maximum safety features

Choose a wagon if:

• Kids are ages 2+ and secured safely
• Using for special trips – beach, park, traveling
• Need to haul lots of additional gear
• Seeking a budget-friendly solution

While both wagons and double strollers transport kids, strollers are the clear winner when it comes to infant and toddler transport. But wagons offer budget utility at the right developmental stage.

Evaluate your family’s needs to pick the choice that provides the most convenience, function, and enjoyment of adventures together!